When Sen. McCain said the economy wasn’t his strong suit, he apparently wasn’t kidding. Today he unveiled his plan – a term which perhaps gives too much credit – to put a moratorium on the federal gas tax during the summer months.
McCain urged Congress to institute a “gas-tax holiday” by suspending the 18.4 cent federal gas tax and 24.4 cent diesel tax from Memorial Day to Labor Day. He also renewed his call for the United States to stop adding to the Strategic Petroleum Reserve and thus lessen to some extent the worldwide demand for oil.
Now I’m no Rhodes scholar, but several red flags went up for me upon hearing about his plan for a tax holiday on gasoline. While it may be “smart politics” on Sen. McCain’s part, it’s terrible policy.
First and foremost, gas prices have risen here in Milwaukee by over 75 cents in the last six months alone. Even if gas prices were to drop by 18 cents overnight, we’d still be paying $3.32 a gallon and there’s nothing to say that the oil companies simply wouldn’t take up the slack by raising pretax prices on top of what they already would in a normal situation to compensate for any lowering of prices.
Second, the federal gas tax funds important highway and infrastructure maintenance programs. It allows us to build new roads, fix old bridges, and most importantly to employ hundreds of thousands of workers. If we suddenly wiped $11 Billion in tax revenue off the books, not only would our infrastructure become more dangerous, thousands of families would suffer due to job loss.
Third, as much as it hurts, higher gas prices are forcing consumers to make smarter choices about what kind of vehicles they buy. It just doesn’t make any sense for the family of three to own a Ford Expedition now that gas isn’t cheap and plentiful. Not that it ever made much sense for a family of three to own a monster of a truck like that anyways, but you get the point.
Finally, imagine the sticker shock on the day after labor day when Sen. McCain’s gas tax holiday ended and prices for gas went up 19 cents overnight.
At the end of the day, a gas tax holiday would provide short term savings to many consumers. But the negative mid to long term impact such a tax holiday would have on this economy are just too important to ignore. McCain’s plan recklessly puts politics before policy; very much to the detriment of the people he’s trying to appease in the first place.



I live in the Washington Heights neighborhood of Milwaukee, WI with my wife Jen, our daughter Emerson, and sons Carter and Colton.
